holmesticemods: (default)
[personal profile] holmesticemods posting in [community profile] holmestice
Title: Hiding Places
Recipient: [livejournal.com profile] eanor
Author: [livejournal.com profile] holyfant
Characters/Pairings: Harry, John
Rating: PG
Word count: 4,700 words
Warnings: swearing
Summary: You're stuck with your family for life, through the good and the bad.



Hiding Places

It's rare, these days, that John will do this for her: abandon his small green soldier toys that she's not allowed to touch and go outside with her. He says it's the rules that she counts to thirty and he only to twenty, and while she's doubtful about this, because no one else has ever told her that, she doesn't mind because she can count to thirty without hesitation now.

He can, too. Easily – he's nine. Not that long ago he counted to one hundred during the night, under his breath, in the bunk bed above her, and she didn't say anything when he finished so he must have thought she was sleeping. Once when she was practicing her counting he kept saying the numbers before she could, and she, filled with a silent, impotent rage, pulled on his hair until she was holding a handful of blond hairs and mum, not angry but something else, called her “Harriet”, sat her on a stool at the kitchen table and told her she had to sit there until she'd calmed down and could tell John sorry. She sat for a long time, counting silently.

It's rare, but it still happens sometimes: he nods in silence when she asks hopefully, then traipses with her from the living room through the back door to the big oak where they always count.

The garden isn't large, but it connects to Eve and Lucas's garden through the hedge, so that's fair game. Only the shed in there is out of bounds, because Lucas's dad works with dangerous tools in there, or at least that's what Lucas says when he's not ignoring Eve and Harry for being girls and being too young to understand.

Harry hides behind the corrugated iron plates that stand against the side of the house. She's never minded the cobwebs, even rather likes spiders, which Eve says isn't okay for girls.

He knows all of her hiding places, and it's rare, these days, but he still searches all of the other ones – behind the hedge on Eve and Lucas's side, beside the mound where dad dumps the grass when he cuts it, behind the triple-trunked birch – before he comes to the iron plates. She can hear him, and doesn't breathe for as long as she can hold it.

“Found you,” he says calmly, and when she comes out, brushing dust from her hair and blinking against the sudden sun, he's smiling, with his hands in the pockets of his short trousers.

-

When Harry is thirteen, she smokes her first cigarette. The fag is a little damp and crinkled from holding it too firmly in her palm during the walk home. She's on the street corner of her street, and she doesn't know what she wants from that – if she wants mum to pass by and see her or absolutely not. Either option is exciting.

She stands, her hip (suddenly there, developed overnight, curved and new and womanly) swung out so her weight rests on one leg. This new, lop-sided way of being in the world makes something inside her tingle – and then she drags in the smoke a little further than her first careful inhales and she loses the tingly feeling in the sudden points of burning in her lungs.

“Do you like it?” Eve asks, eyes narrowed in suspicious observation.

“I – yes,” Harry half-lies, then coughs until the hot point of burning in her chest recedes a little. She takes another drag, wondering at the actually quite unpleasant bitter taste, at the feeling of smoke, at the idea of it. She manages to breathe out without coughing this time. Her throat feels like sand when she swallows, and somehow it's perfect, it's wonderful this way.

“Let us try, then,” Eve says, stepping closer, eager, biting her lip (pink and raw and shiny).

“He didn't give it to you,” Harry croaks, and angles the cigarette away, dangling between her fingers like a casual, disappearing treasure.

“Well, I gave you the lighter, didn't I?” Eve retorts, scowling. “Besides, you don't even know him. Let me.

Harry ignores her – Eve, pink and shiny and lips bitten raw, still unable to part with her pigtails, with her backpack high on her back. She doesn't have the power on this corner, not with Harry standing there with her elbow on her hip and her uniform skirt hitched up. She feels tall and she feels good.

“Fine,” Eve snaps. “Be a – be a bitch.” She turns and stalks away, the effect slightly spoiled by the sight of her yellow backpack.

“See you tomorrow,” Harry calls gleefully after her, with a rush of unexplained pleasure, and she drops the cigarette, only half-smoked, to the pavement and steps on it to put it out.

At home, John looks up from his comic book when she comes in and raises his eyebrows at her while their mother fusses over her and tells her to never do that again I was so worried, but that's it. She can feel his eyes following her when she crosses the living room to go upstairs. Say something, she dares him, surely you can smell it.

He's silent, flips a page in his comic.

It feels like a victory, going up the stairs with the taste of smoke still in the back of her throat; it doesn't matter that she doesn't really know in what fight.

-

Harry kisses Eve when they're fifteen, and Eve giggles before letting her.

“Feels good,” she says breathlessly, and Harry has to agree; good and warm and not enough. She kisses Eve again, moistly and warmly, and feels something filling the lowest point of her belly, like she's had a cup of hot chocolate.

“Let's try it with tongue this time,” Eve says after they re-surface, and she looks flushed and keen and bright in the pool of sunlight trickling in through the shed window, murky with dust.

“Okay,” Harry agrees quickly, and lets Eve start it this time, and savours the burst of heat through her entire body when Eve's tongue comes to press at her lips. When she lets it in, it is slippery and hot and wet, and too big and not enough. Without really thinking, she tangles a hand into Eve's curls, and moves their bodies closer, and Eve makes a sound, a small sound, and curls an arm around Harry's shoulder.

They break apart, and Eve's lashes are tipped with a dusty trail of sunlight.

“This was a great idea,” Eve whispers, and Harry nods dumbly. “This is such good practice for later.”

The jolt that goes through Harry is not pleasant. When Eve kisses her again, it only feels half as good, and she doesn't know why.

-

“Come on, Harry,” John says, and he sounds more annoyed at her than anything, which makes something in her calm down a little – a wild, primal fear that had bloomed. “It's not – it's not that bad, it'll –”

“Blow over?” she asks, and angrily wipes her eyes with the back of her hand. “It'll only – blow over when – when I go back in there and tell them that – that it wasn't true, that I was just –” She stops, and bites her lip, shiny and raw, and winces at the tell-tale sting when the skin splits.

John hands her her coat, huffs when she doesn't take it and drapes it over her shoulders. “I wasn't going to say blow over,” he says, sounding almost offended, and it seems like such a stupid thing to say in the face of what she's trying to articulate through the distorting spikes of fear and anger pounding inside her skull that she almost laughs. She goes a little stiller, holds her a fingertip to her left eye and catches new tears on it. Very suddenly, she almost feels okay again, and it's a little disorienting, this sudden return of calm.

“I was leaving this place anyway,” she says. With shaking fingers, she feels around in her pocket for her cigarettes with her free hand and doesn't find them.

“You're only eighteen,” he says, frowning.

“I can stay with you in Chelmsford,” she says, and when she blinks there are more tears on her fingertip. “Can't I?”

He blinks as well, and clears his throat. His breath rises in a white cloud. “You can't just... They're angry now, but I'm sure they won't...” He trails off and licks his lips. “I have housemates, Harry. I don't have room for you.”

She closes her eyes and wishes, desperately, for a cigarette, and for different parents. The intensity of the thought, brief though it is, makes something in her chest clench painfully.

“Okay,” she says, like it doesn't feel like her last hope has just been dashed.

He's silent for a while, fidgeting lightly in that way that sometimes really rubs her the wrong way. She grits her teeth and doesn't tell him to stop, because he's the only one that's out here with her tonight. It's his only night at home for another fourteen days, and inside she can imagine with painful clarity how her mother must be complaining, tearfully, that John is only here for one night and why won't he come in.

“They think I'm doing this to wind them up,” she tells him eventually, quietly. The birches, leafless, rustle in the winter evening. “They don't even think... They can't even conceive of how hard it is for me to tell them this. They think I'm just having a go at them.”

“I don't think so,” John says after a couple of beats. “Mum asked me a couple of months earlier if I thought you were... Well.”

“Gay.” It's a bitter word, that bursts in her mouth like unripe fruit.

He clears his throat. “Yeah,” he says, has the gall to sound apologetic.

“Bet she was just terrified.” There is no joy in it.

John neither confirms nor denies, simply jams his hands deeper in his pockets. It's an answer like any other.

“So what did you say?” she asks him, and blows her breath skyward in lieue of actual smoke. It's endlessly unsatisfying. There are a lot of stars out, cold, useless dots of pinprick light.

“That I didn't know.”

“You did know,” she says.

“Not my place,” he says calmly, and she does have a passing thought about how it must be so easy, to have it not be your place, to have your place be on the safety of the sidelines, and to be able to say afterwards that you so faithfully kept a secret that was never even yours to keep, that never put any weight on your shoulders at all.

“Yeah,” she says, and watches the words freeze upwards. “I suppose not.”

-

“Be happy,” John tells Harry, smiling widely, fiddling fruitlessly with his tie.

“I already am,” she says, and looks over to where Clara is standing, a ginger-haired vision in a green wedding dress, and feels her heart expand until it overtakes all of her; and later this moment will be to blame, this moment in which she said that she was happy, in which she invited life's arrows to take aim at her.

“Thanks, John,” she says, and touches her brother's shoulder.

-

“Oh, don't, Harry, please,” John says, and he presses his thumbs briefly to the skin under his eyes (dark and heavy and raw).

“I'm sorry,” she says, wrist deep in soap and dishes, and she's annoyed that her voice sounds liquid, like water ready to be poured. She sounds drowned, which isn't fair, not now, not now she's trying so hard. He comes to stand next to her and leans a hip against the table top.

“This is a party,” he tells her, holding up a finger like an admonishing mother. Their mother never did that. “One you insisted on throwing, if I must remind you.” Inside the living room, there is the murmur of the small number of people that they share. The timbre of Clara's laugh, low and short and not tinkling and light like usual, means that someone – probably mum – has made a completely inappopriate joke that Clara will complain about later, in bed, half-offended, half-amused. Harry likes it when she does that, because she gets heated in her arguments with herself.

“It's the only way I can get you to come here, bastard,” she says, smiling a little, eyes stinging, holding between her fingertips the soapy fragility of one of the crystal wine glasses that Clara loves, even now that they only drink apple juice out of them.

He smiles at her, genuine and rare. John smiles for a lot of reasons, and not all of them are good. This is a good one, despite the complexity of this evening and of him, in this kitchen.

“I'll be all right.”

“You're going to war.”

They never contradict each other directly. It's not their way. He looks her in the eye. He doesn't seem afraid of anything, and that is how he has always looked to her, from the earliest of memories. “I'll be fine,” he says.

And she says, because she has to, because he is here to receive blessings, to receive as much goodwill as he can carry: “Okay.”

In the living room, uncle Peter sings the opening bars of God Save the Queen without words, just off-key beats of throaty song. Doo doo doo doo dedoo, doo doo doo doo dedoo. Like he's misplaced the words somewhere.

-

“Go on,” she says, baring her teeth at him. “Go and say it, then.”

John, war-stained, London-winter-washed, looks like he wants to break something. If she knows him, which she does, it's probably himself he's thinking of, because he still can't really conceive of breaking something else. They're Watsons. Underneath, they're still the same. He shoots people who would kill him and destroys himself over it. She drinks. At least there's no collateral damage in her war.

“I don't know what you're talking about,” he says from the doorframe, and lifts his chin in unspoken defiance.

“At least I'm still more of a mess than you are, right? Isn't that what you're thinking? Still ever the older brother, am I right?” she says, and it's like nails on a chalk board, she knows, she can see it in the way he bites down on nothing, on words that he must think but never says.

“Yeah, that makes me really happy, as you know,” he finally says, the words thin and bitter, pushed past the barrier of his narrow mouth, his lips unwilling.

She hooks an arm over her eyes, blocking him out. The sheets of her bed feel dirty against her; they stick to her, with her sweat and her spilled alcohol and her tears, which are the same. Clara would have a fit. Harry's insides tighten with nausea at the thought.

“Leave me alone,” she says. Behind the blackness of her closed eyelids there is still the knowledge of the room and how it spins, how the corners fold away in the glaring light of the aftermath.

He stays there for a long moment. “No,” he finally says, but he leaves anyway, and takes all of the alcohol he can find with him.

He doesn't know all of her hiding places, not anymore, and he must know this. He must.

-

John does call, every time, when he leaves without really talking. It will almost be as though the neighbours never called him and he never showed up, he never put her to bed or tried to get her out of it, he never poured the contents of her liquor cabinet down the sink as she sat at the table and hated him with such vigour he must have felt it like a physical energy.

He'll say, like that never happened: “Look, let me help.”

She'll want to say: “Why don't you ever stay? That might help.”

She doesn't, because he times his calls somehow, by some inner Watson compass maybe, and she's usually more or less sober, and more than less repentant. There is always pain in these phone calls.

She'll say: “It's not your responsibility.”

He'll disagree vehemently, so strongly she'll stuff her hand in her mouth to stop herself from crying or from getting really angry or maybe both, and he'll send her e-mails with contact information about AA meetings in her area. He doesn't offer to go with her, and there is no one else, and in the end she just can't do it, so she doesn't go.

-

“So who the fuck is this bloke?” Harry, wide-eyed with anticipation, asks John when he comes to visit and stands awkwardly in the hall, tracing where the pictures of Clara were with his eyes. “What the hell is going on with you?”

John laughs the freest laugh she's seen him laugh since he returned, scarred in different ways.

“He's... It's even a little hard to just describe him,” he says, shaking his head.

“God knows I've got time!” Harry says.

-

“So are you... doing okay?” he asks her over her birthday dinner. There's no one else in her house; all of the friends she had were more of the pub type, and she can't do that anymore. This way, though, with just the two of them, it's really starting to feel like the sense of obligation that's keeping them both there is wearing thin. They know, by now, that they're only good for each other in small doses.

“Yes,” she says, tense.

“Good,” he says carefully, and eats her vegetarian shepherd's pie like he actually enjoys it.

“You?”

“Yes,” he says, and the answer is direct and solid, which makes her smile a little in a very automatic sort of way. “I mean,” he says, because Watsons know it's bad luck to say that they're happy. “Sherlock's been preoccupied with this case. It's...” he hesitates. “It's pretty complex.”

“Well, go ahead then. I do love me a good whodunit,” Harry says, and smiles at him over her glass of mineral water.

-

“Oh my God, you're fucking gay for him, aren't you?” Harry says, eyes wide with mirth.

John sighs in his put-upon way. “Not you, too.”

“No, but seriously,” she says, feeling her mouth fold into a wide smile. “Listen to yourself. Sherlock this, Sherlock that, Sherlock shits fucking diamonds, Sherlock knows the secrets to the universe! You're besotted!”

John scowls deeply, takes a swig of the non-alcoholic beer he's accepted without comment, trying to be supportive. “No, okay. It's not like that at all.”

She grins at him, tapping her fingers against the metal of her beer can. “Ooooooh, Sherlock,” she croons. “Deduce me. Yes, like that.”

John slams his beer down on the coffee table with a sudden and surprising sound of anger. The smile slides off her face as he points a finger at her. “You of all people,” he says, then sucks in an audible breath. “You of all people must know how offensive it is when people just assume things,” he finishes uncharacteristically acidly.

“Hey, Johnny, it's okay, I was just teasing,” she says, frowning, wondering where she'd lost the thread of the conversation so much he could get so angry so suddenly. It's not like him.

“Don't call me Johnny,” he snaps.

“All right, John,” she says tartly. “Don't get so worked up.”

“It's exhausting to listen to this,” he says, the words clipped, and moves to get up.

She watches him as he walks over to his coat, draped over a chair, and feels the stirrings of an old anger. “Yeah,” she finally agrees, “it is exhausting. It's exhausting when people think they know things about you just because you happen to have sex that they can't imagine being real sex, or relationships that they think can only come from some sort of trauma or some mental illness or whatever.”

He rests his hands on his coat, and doesn't turn towards her, but also doesn't move to put it on.

“Jesus fuck, John,” she bites, “I'm sorry if I upset you, but this wasn't fucking malicious. I won't mention it again. You know I don't fucking care what you do, whether it's settling down with some blue-eyed clear-skinned doctor type in a house with a picket fence and having two point one children or if it's getting, I dunno, suspended from the ceiling and buggered by your frankly socially handicapped and clinically insane flatmate. I don't give a fuck. It's me, you moron.” She watches him, the tense lines of his neck and shoulders. “You have this happen to you once and you think you know what it's like.” She shakes her head. “Sorry, but you've been the one making those kinds of jokes about me for ages. I never complained. I was happy that you felt comfortable enough to joke about it, even if your jokes were terrible.” She scoffs and sits back in her armchair.

He turns towards her. He doesn't look angry anymore. His eyes are large and his mouth is thin.

“I –” he says, then seems to be at a loss.

“Don't say sorry,” she says, suddenly tired. “It's fine.”

He comes back and sits down, clearly ill at ease. He finished his non-pint slowly, thoughtfully, and when he does finally get up he thanks her, with all of the grace of a wooden doll.

-

“Hey, look, I'm sorry, okay,” John, removed, on the phone, says, but he sounds more annoyed than sorry.

“Yeah, fat lot of good that does,” she responds angrily, squashing the desire the chuck her phone into the burning hearth. “Christmas is in two days, you wanker.”

“It's Sherlock, okay? He... I dunno. He's got this... thing. I can't really leave him alone right now.”

“Oh, yeah, right,” Harry says. “Sherlock's got a thing. Very important.”

“It is, actually,” John says, sounding strained, and she's reminded why they don't do this anymore, why they don't really call, not since he had to come and scrape her off the floor every few weeks and couldn't seem to stomach talking to her directly: because face to face they can at least grimace and frown and clench their jaws. This is stunted, this, like trying to walk with a blindfold on. It's no wonder they were never able to help each other before.

“Yeah, great. Thanks for letting me know on time and for having a totally legitimate reason,” Harry bites. “You do know, John, that he's just playing you so you'll stay with him? He hates me and he thinks you shouldn't see me.”

“Don't be ridiculous,” John says, and it's in a voice she knows all too well, a voice Clara used to call the I'm-Harry-and-I-will-belittle-your-opinion-voice. (And that was when she was still feeling charitable.)

“Yeah, whatever. Talk to you later.” She ends the call before John can respond and throws her phone onto the sofa, where it bounces and drops to the floor.

-

John whats going on


Im looking at it on
the news



Missed call: Harry
June 15 2012, 10:23


Voicemail received
June 15 2012, 10:24


Missed call: Harry
June 15 2012, 11:14


Missed call: Harry
June 15 2012, 11:16


Voicemail received
June 15, 11:16


John pick up ur
fucking phone ok



Missed call: Harry
June 15 2012, 12:57


John come on
pick up


Let me help



Missed call: Harry
June 15 2012, 13:02


Missed call: Harry
June 15 2012, 14:33


John please


If ur getting this
please pick up



Missed call: Harry
June 15 2012, 16:22


Ok fine but im coming
over tomorrow


-

“Don't you dare,” John says when she opens her mouth, and for the first time since he let her into the flat he looks her straight in the eye.

“Don't I dare what? Tell you that your friend was a fucking lunatic who tricked you? A top-class psycho?” she snarls, beaten raw with the presence of him, his huge mournful presence, sucking all of the light in the room towards him and extinguishing it.

John seems to grow, like the anger physically fills him. “Shut the fuck up,” he says, the words like lashes, and he never says fuck, it's always her who says fuck and John who rolls his eyes at it.

She shuts the fuck up and goes to his kitchen, slamming the cupboard doors, and then dropping the tea cups because her hands won't stop shaking.

-

It's strange that his headstone doesn't have any dates. Think you're too good for a date of birth, you fucker? she thinks, and jams her hands in her pocket, savouring the prickle of sudden anger.

It really is a weird sort of grave. SHERLOCK HOLMES, it says, on black mirroring stone. She remembers John telling her Sherlock enjoyed deducing details about everyone. Well then, she thinks, and lowers herself, crouching until she's looking at herself, his name branded across her forehead. Deduce me if you can.

He's dead, of course. Not that special after all. A mere mortal stepping off a ledge. The borders are closed. And stone is just stone, cold and unspeaking.

She shakes her head a little, thinking of the time he'd turned towards her in his and John's flat on Baker Street while John was in the bathroom, and had said: “I hope you realise you make life difficult for him,” and she'd lashed out, already tense from John's wariness around her and Sherlock's intense focus and complete inability to stick to normal social codes. “You can fuck right off,” she'd said.

He'd raised an eyebrow.

Bastard.

She had made things difficult for John sometimes, as had he for her. If she were a better person she might have told Sherlock that then, or John some other time. She might have said that that is what family does, and that people who don't hurt you don't usually matter that much.

“You can still fuck right off,” she tells the headstone. “Where do you get off telling me I make things difficult for him. Look at the state of you, you unbelievable dick.” There is something sharp and jagged in her throat, something that she can't swallow away. “He still believes in you, which is stupid, because there is so much evidence. I'm sure you'd tell him off for that, with your stupid scientific... stuff.” She takes a moment to appreciate that she's talking to a gravestone, and she shakes her head at herself.

She looks off-coloured in the headstone, but she can still tell that she really needs to brush her hair. Well. “Thanks, Sherlock, nice of you to let me know,” she says, barely suppressing a smile, which immediately fades when she hears the sound of footsteps on the leaf-strewn grass behind her.

John is frowning deeply at her when she turns around. He doesn't look angry. She'd prepared for some sort of anger, resentment at her for being there maybe, or just general persisting rage for this grave and this graveyard and the fact that his best friend is silent and still and decomposing where they stand. She doesn't quite know what to do now that the anger is absent.

“What are you doing here?” he asks, sounding resigned.

“Nothing,” she says, a little defensively.

He steps up next to her, and they both face the grave.

“It's an odd sort of grave,” she says after several beats of silence, and then frowns at herself. John, however, is smiling a little when he turns towards her.

“Well, he was odd,” he says, and with that the smile goes. But it's something. It's more than enough.

They stand for a while longer. “Hey,” Harry says finally. “I actually came here because you haven't been returning my calls. You're a prick, by the way.” John's mouth does an almost-smile sort of thing. “So I thought I should come here to look for you.”

They're reflected together in Sherlock Holmes' headstone, short and stocky and strangely off-coloured. Watsons through and through.

“Well,” John says quietly. “You found me.”

“Yes,” she says just as quietly, and touches his sleeve. “Found you.”

Date: 2012-12-08 07:15 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] radialarch.livejournal.com
This is incredible. The Harry you've drawn is believable, sympathetic, but still rough-edged and all the more interesting for it. Just. Wow.

Date: 2012-12-08 10:46 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] eanor.livejournal.com
Wow, dear Anon, thank you so very much!! :-)

I love your portrayal of Harry as a truly believable, well-rounded character with rough edges and shortcomings, but very likeable in her own way, too. The little glimpses of her life you show us are all very well chosen and meaningful. I especially liked how her relationship with John changed over the years - for me that's what this story was truly about. It's easy to see in which ways John and Harry are similar - both are stubborn and do what they want to do, both care about each other, can't really help the other, but try anyway. The "Watson" trades you called them and I really liked these similarities - but their differences as well! This is a completely believable backstory for John and Harry and will be my headcanon from now on.

I also loved the theme of the different hiding places that runs through the whole piece and how up until the end it's always Harry hiding and then you reversed it masterfully. It's also interesting to see Harry interact with Sherlock's headstone only, but it still feels like an interaction with the real Sherlock.

I really loved this story! Thank you very much! :-D

Date: 2013-01-05 03:37 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] holyfant.livejournal.com
I'm glad to hear you enjoyed it! :) You had so many prompts and so many ideas in your signup post and I kept going back and forth between them going I WANT TO DO THEM ALL, but I settled for doing just a small part of it, which I hope you didn't mind. Sibling dynamics are one of my favourite things to write about and you gave me a perfect opportunity for that. So thanks for the prompts :D and I'm really really happy to hear you liked it!

Date: 2013-01-05 05:41 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] eanor.livejournal.com
I realize only belatedly how very scary my signup must have been with all the different prompts! I just wanted to give you various ideas to choose from, so you did the absolute right thing concentrating on one of them. Plus, I absolutely love the result - such a lovely character study / study of the Watsons' sibling relationship. Thanks again! :-)

Date: 2012-12-08 01:29 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] obscuriglobus.livejournal.com
This was wonderful

Date: 2012-12-08 03:57 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] solrosan.livejournal.com
Beautiful portrayal of Harry and the Watson siblings' relationship. Thank you!

Date: 2012-12-08 08:59 pm (UTC)
innie_darling: (incarnadine softness)
From: [personal profile] innie_darling
This whole thing is just flat-out fantastic, but the section where John's about to go off to war and Harry's throwing a party for him hit me especially hard.

Date: 2012-12-09 12:51 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] what-alchemy.livejournal.com
Hands down the best Harry Watson I've ever read.

This is the kind of story that brings in a character we never see in the source material and manages to enhance the characterization of those we do see. John is perfect here -- the put upon elder brother who doesn't realize when he gets it wrong. This is exactly how family works.

It doesn't hurt that this is written so well. My favorite line:

This new, lop-sided way of being in the world makes something inside her tingle

Gorgeous, wonderful, thank you.

Date: 2012-12-09 06:02 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ruth0007.livejournal.com
“Well,” John says quietly. “You found me.”
“Yes,” she says just as quietly, and touches his sleeve. “Found you.”

What a tender and thoughtful piece on John and Harry. i really enjoyed how you developed and examined their relationship. (I wonder if we'll see Harry in Season 3?)

Date: 2012-12-11 05:54 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] impulsereader.livejournal.com
Wow. Well, I just copied and came down here to paste in as a comment the first instance of John doing this: “Found you,” he says calmly

...and now I've spoiled myself. This is fantastically written so I shall just roll my eyes at myself and scroll back up to continue on. :-)

Back now (sorry, this is just how I tend to comment - as I go :-) - this story is absolutely gorgeous. I've made it to: They never contradict each other directly. It's not their way. I'm alternately loving the truth of that as you have presented it here and falling over laughing about the next bit where Uncle Whosis is humming as if he misplaced the words of God Save the Queen. You are pulling at my heartstrings in a very serious manner here. Over Harry - an OC for whom I have little to no sympathy. You are a consummate storyteller, anon.

Oh - the John and Harry at dinner - guh - he really has no idea. He's the one always spouting off (clearly [mostly] joking) about how people will talk and then flipping out about being labeled a confirmed bachelor - this is bitterness presented exactly as it should be.

Oh, sigh, this was lovely. I absolutely love Harry telling Sherlock to fuck right off. As she should. Family etc.

This was so well done! It is both wonderful within the world of Sherlock and clearly its own entity altogether. Amazing. Thank you so much for sharing this.

Date: 2012-12-12 05:32 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ureshiiichigo.livejournal.com
Oh, my goodness. This was utterly gorgeous. I love this look into Harry's mind and her relationship with John.

I especially loved this line: She might have said that that is what family does, and that people who don't hurt you don't usually matter that much.

Date: 2012-12-16 04:54 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] musamihi.livejournal.com
This is such a wonderful story in so many ways - the prose itself is awesome, economical but beautiful, quiet and efficient but with such marvelous little pauses for flashes of something concrete. Eve's lashes are tipped with a dusty trail of sunlight, and she's annoyed that her voice sounds liquid, like water ready to be poured, and he thanks her, with all of the grace of a wooden doll - there are so many of these. I really admire an author who can just stop to appreciate things that are beautiful in their own right while still maintaining the emotional through-line of a story like this one.

What I appreciate the most, I think, is that you've given a voice to a character who tends to get kicked around in canon as a way to canonize John Watson - you've made her more than an easy way for the writers to characterize John, you've made her a person. There's something really powerful in that, particularly considering the gendered aspect to the way canon treats Harry as a tool, and you've done it very simply and honestly and effectively. The way Harry's wounded by the thought of just being practice for later; the way you relocate the pain of alcoholism and having to deal with homophobia onto her, not her brother (it must be so easy, to have it not be your place, to have your place be on the safety of the sidelines, and to be able to say afterwards that you so faithfully kept a secret that was never even yours to keep, that never put any weight on your shoulders at all); Harry calling John out on making jokes about her being gay while being offended that anyone might think he was. It makes me so happy to read all of this, and I love that you've fit it into a framework of a very realistic and flawed relationship that nonetheless gets a hopeful ending - two siblings, both of whom have problems that are all too real, but who still love each other, whatever good that does them.

In short, I think you are probably a brilliant person and just - brava.

Date: 2013-01-06 04:04 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] holyfant.livejournal.com
I just want to reply to this comment because it's awesome! I love your response to this, especially the bit about making Harry something more than just a tool to characterise John - that was definitely something I wanted to do, so it's great to hear that I managed it. She's not likely to get a voice in the show's canon, I suppose, and it's always nice (and empowering, I find) to take characters like that and lift them beyond just x and y characteristic. With the things we know about her she could be a very interesting character.

Thanks for this comment, it made me smile - and I've already re-read it a couple of times, haha.

Date: 2012-12-16 06:45 pm (UTC)
ext_9241: Lost in Translation (John # Russel Square)
From: [identity profile] poetic-self.livejournal.com
This has an awesome pace and a really good eye for the small things. It's a little like I know them and a little like I get to see something I've never seen before. It's also really well-observed and heart-clenchingly well written. Hats off.

Date: 2012-12-25 02:45 am (UTC)
ext_3554: dream wolf (Default)
From: [identity profile] keerawa.livejournal.com
I was about to say that your Harry was fantastically in-character, but then I realized there's no canon for me to judge by! So, perhas it's better to comment that THIS is what John Watson's little sister, and their relationship, must be, and that from now on I plan to adopt it as my canon.

Date: 2012-12-25 03:51 am (UTC)
ext_3554: dream wolf (Default)
From: [identity profile] keerawa.livejournal.com
I was about to say that your Harry was fantastically in-character, but then I realized there's no canon for me to judge by! So, perhas it's better to comment that THIS is what John Watson's little sister, and their relationship, must be, and that from now on I plan to adopt it as my canon.

Date: 2012-12-25 05:34 am (UTC)
ext_3554: dream wolf (Default)
From: [identity profile] keerawa.livejournal.com
I was about to say that your Harry was fantastically in-character, but then I realized there's no canon for me to judge by! So, perhas it's better to comment that THIS is what John Watson's little sister, and their relationship, must be, and that from now on I plan to adopt it as my canon.

Date: 2013-01-06 12:26 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] missyvortexdv.livejournal.com
Melancholy but in a pleasant way almost like they're at the end on the cusp of being better. It feels like Harry is tired somehow, being who she is, having had to fight so much she doesn't know when not to. I like the exploration of her past, this was a good read.

Date: 2013-01-07 08:39 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] saki101.livejournal.com
This is beautiful. Out of a few shreds of canon ("Harry and I have never gotten on...") you've revealed (because it does seem this is who she must be) a complex and rounded character who intersects with John and Sherlock in a way that fits perfectly. The scenes you've highlighted in her life, her relationship with John, show her, and John, unfolding, neither perfect, but still connected.

I would have to quote back every line to you to list everything I admired, but the scene over the dishes before John goes to Afghanistan, with the soapy wine glass only used for apple juice at the time, is a particular favourite. John may well be going away to die and he chooses that despite how it might make those close to him feel. Another is that brief exchange with Sherlock and, of course, the ending scene by the grave. She knew where to find him. But it does the story injustice to select any part of it; it is such a unified work, each line supporting what follows.

Thank you!

April 2026

S M T W T F S
    1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Apr. 11th, 2026 01:11 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios