Yeah - plus, we wouldn't get the "two gifts" scenario if they were both by the same person. One would be posted as a treat.
I've thought about it a little more. I initially rejected edosianorchids901 as an option because that author so rarely writes romantic H/W, but after further review, A Secret Thought is actually in approximately the same style as Until the Sunlight Hits (written earlier this year for kingstoken). Also, while I don't know who most of the pinch-hitters are in this exchange, I know edosianorchids901 wrote me a lovely fic (Destiny) as a pinch-hit in Unsent Letters last year. I'm switching my guess to edosianorchids901.
Re: Part 3: Fic
I've thought about it a little more. I initially rejected