Okay! I have some guesses this time, yay! Spent the morning rewatching the videos (which are all amazing!) and checking against offers and talking myself in circles about who did them, lol.

First, I watched Nightcall and I thought it had to be Dovah-because the lump in my throat-seriously, every time I watch a vid by Dovah it hits me right in the feels. But, they did not offer Sherlock & Mycroft. But rachelindeed did-so my official guess for Nightcall is rachelindeed. Changed my mind. rachelindeed did not offer BBC, so I think this one actually was knowmefirst.

Before the Rain I'm going to guess is pagimag, because they offered John/other and this one definitely drew attention not only to John/Sherlock and John/Mary, but John/Sholto as well.

Mr. Holmes Beekeeper I'm going to guess sanguinity, based entirely on the wide variety of fandoms they offered. Although, I had thought maybe a pinch hitter, too.

That leaves Sleepless Nights, Empty Days for Dovah. BBC, Sherlock/John and sure enough, it has that angsty post Reichenbach feel that brings a tear to your eye, which is right up their alley.

Okay, walking away now before I can talk myself out of all my guesses!